Member Log In

Pets for Patriots

Companion pet adoption for United States military veterans and service members

  • Adopt a pet
    • How it works
    • Veteran benefits
    • Program availability
    • Proof of service
    • Eligible pets
    • Pre-qual application
  • Be a veterinary partner
    • How it works
    • Benefits
    • Criteria & eligibility
    • Application
  • Be a shelter partner
    • How it works
    • Benefits
    • Eligible pets
    • Criteria & eligibility
    • Application
  • Donate Now
    • Donate online
    • Ways to give
    • Spread the word
  • More
    • About us
      • Vision
      • Mission
      • Our team
      • Board of Directors
      • Financial accountability
      • Year in review
      • Program availability
    • Making an impact
      • Forget Me Not
      • The Wet Nose Blog
      • Partner News
      • Donor News
      • Home at last
      • Welcome Home
      • Hotel to Home
    • Friends & Partners
      • Veterinarian partners
      • Shelter partners
      • Sponsors
      • Banfield
      • VIP Petcare
      • Community partners
    • Resources
      • Donor FAQ
      • Veteran FAQ
      • Shelter FAQ
      • Veterinarian FAQ
      • Other resources
    • Connect with us
      • In the news
      • Free wallpaper
      • Contact us
Wet Nose Blog
Home › Extra › Deed not breed: why more shelters are joining the no label movement

Deed not breed: why more shelters are joining the no label movement

March 6, 2017Extra

Deed not breed: why more shelters are joining the no label movement

Many animal welfare advocates encourage would-be adopters to focus on characteristics that are far more important than breed when it comes to choosing a dog. A new no label movement emphasizing other aspects of dogs’ personalities is changing how canines are being promoted – and it is working.

Getting to know you

In an effort to overcome the inaccurate notoriety attached to some breeds, shelters across the United State are refusing to label dogs according to the breed they appear to be. Animals who were formerly seen as undesirable because they resembled canines that are thought to be fierce are now finding willing adopters and loving homes.

Increased adoption rates are the most notable – and important – outcome of the no label movement.

For Savanna New at Florida’s Jacksonville Humane Society and a volunteer with Pets For Patriots, this is a welcome development. The shelter has been a Pets for Patriots partner since 2011, and in 2016 its Community Animal Hospital joined our veterinary partner program. 

“All across the country,” she says, “perfectly gentle dogs are sitting in shelters for months on end because they ‘look like’ a breed that has a reputation for being aggressive. Dogs are like people. Each one has a totally unique personality.”

That is how Jacksonville Humane Society wants the public to view the animals in its care.

“Instead of looking at the breed,” says Savanna, “we want people to get to know the individual dog.”

The vast majority of dogs who enter shelters are mixed-breed animals – which actually means they are not any breed. Since a dog’s appearance is the result of as little as a quarter of one percent of its entire DNA, a canine that “looks like” a Pit Bull, for example, may indeed be a Labrador mix, a Pit mix, or multiple different breeds in one.

Looks can be misleading

Dogs who resemble Pit Bulls – a blanket designation used to label what are actually four different breeds of Terrier – suffer the most from this unfortunate breed labeling. In one study conducted at the University of Arizona it was found that Pit Bull-type dogs remained in a shelter over three times longer than similarly large breeds like Labradors and Boxers. The no label movement seeks to redress this wrong.

Deed not breed: why more shelters are joining the no label movement

According to the ASPCA, Pit Bulls make up up more than 20 percent of the dog population in many shelters. Of the nearly four million dogs that enter such facilities each year, over 30 percent are euthanized. One can easily imagine how many of them suffer this fate solely because they are Pit Bull-lookalikes that have been in residence for just too long. 

This is unfair to the dog, says Savanna, and to a potential guardian. Whatever its appearance, the animal’s other inherited genes may give it the playfulness of a Lab, the gentleness of a Pug and the stamina of an Australian Cattle Dog. And for a canine who could have become a member of a loving family, these are the characteristics that really matter.

Even for a dog whose genetic makeup shows that it really is one of the four Pit Bull breeds, people should not be unduly worried. Contrary to common prejudices, these dogs are not inherently dangerous. As with any dog, proper training from a young age can make them into gentle, obedient, friendly animals – who are great with children.

Shelter dogs suffer from breed mislabeling 

Dogs are notoriously difficult to identify by their appearance.

In a study by the University of Florida College of Veterinary Medicine, dog experts were able to correctly identify the breed of an animal only one time in four. The experts in the study included veterinarians, breeders and trainers. The average shelter worker who is forced to play this kind of guessing game has an even poorer chance of getting the breed right. 

This comparison of dog photos with actual DNA results and user surveys shows the glaring inaccuracy of visual breed identifications.

The companies that make computer programs for animal shelters have contributed to the problem. Until recently, most of the software required the person doing the data entry to select a breed from a drop-down list of as many as 250 choices.

Invariably, the four Pit Bull designations were on the list. More important, neither “mixed breed” nor “American shelter dog” were offered as choices. Adding to the difficulty, shelter workers who were uncertain were prohibited from skipping the question. 

Removing breed labels can have a noticeable influence on adoption rates. When such information was omitted from kennel cards in one study cited in the The Veterinary Journal, 64 percent of Pit Bulls were adopted – up from 52 percent when the “negative” detail was on display. And there was a 12 percent reduction in the euthanasia of the animals. It is results such as this, not marketing or trickery, that is fueling the no breed movement.

Get to know the inner dog

The alternative to breed labeling on kennel cards and websites is actually quite simple. Staff strive to get to know the unique animal for who she is and describe her that way.

“We want potential adopters to look that individual dog in the eye, experience its friendly disposition, and fall in love with its cute ways,” says Jacksonville Humane Society’s Savanna New.

Deed not breed: why more shelters are joining the no label movement

Shelter visitors considering adoption are urged to take the dog into the play yard for what Savanna calls a “meet and greet.” That way they can become acquainted with the dog, and experience first-hand its behavior and singular personality.

Getting to know the dog on an individual level is a primary goal at Jacksonville Humane Society. Details about the animal’s liveliness, sociability, and other characteristics are recorded by volunteers and staff in the dog’s computer profile. These details are relayed to people who show an interest in adopting.

Another valuable source of information is the shelter’s SleepOver Program. Potential adopters are permitted to take the animal home for a trial run to see how she gets along with the other people and pets in the household. Even if the dog is not adopted by that family, shelter personnel ask questions about this key behavioral information. 

“We also learn a lot through observing a dog in play groups,” says Savanna. “We want to know whether it enjoys the company of other dogs.”

Potentially negative information is never withheld by the shelter, though it may be couched in positive terms.

A dog who might not be suitable for a home with small children, for example, may be described as more appropriate for a home with children “in middle school or above.” A dog who is extremely active may be suggested as a great partner “for people who are avid runners or bikers.”

When a family comes to Jacksonville Humane Society’s facility in search of a particular breed of dog, the staff is similarly proactive. If adopters are seeking a Labrador, for example, workers and volunteers are trained to ask why they prefer that breed. A typical response might be that Labradors are known to be good with kids and generally playful.

“When that happens,” says Savanna, “our adoption counselors know exactly what to say: ’This mixed-breed dog over here just had a sleepover with a family of eight kids. She got along great with everybody, from the baby to the teenager. And she’s also super playful. Come out into our play yard for a meet and greet.’”

No label movement changing minds – and laws

If animals are to benefit fully from the no label movement, community norms and laws need to change as well.

It is estimated that over 700 US cities have enacted breed-specific legislation, known as BSL. These are designed to prohibit the ownership of animals that are thought to be dangerous to the public. Unsurprisingly, dogs who are labeled as Pit Bulls are disproportionally targeted by BSL.

In one southern city, a person who wishes to own a Pit Bull, for example, must obtain an annual “potentially-dangerous breed” permit and a city license, as well as a window sticker that provides proof the dog has been sterilized and micro-chipped. Besides being prohibited from using an invisible fence to contain the animal, the homeowner may not own more than two “potentially dangerous” breeds at that residence.

But here too attitudes are softening.

Deed not breed: why more shelters are joining the no label movement

Recognizing the inherent difficulties in breed identification– and the fact that there is no convincing evidence that BSL has ever succeeded in preventing dog attacks – the ASPCA is pushing for a change to “breed-neutral” legislation. Dog owners, not the animals themselves, would be held accountable for the aggressive behavior of their pets. This is what people refer to when they encourage others to focus on deed, not breed.

And the ASPCA is not alone. Groups as diverse as the American Veterinary Medical Association, the American Bar Association, the American Kennel Club – and even the White House – condemn BSL as ineffective at promoting public safety.

The initiative appears to be having an effect. In 2016 when Arizona banned discrimination against Pit Bulls it became the 20th state to eliminate laws that forbade or otherwise regulated dogs by breed. 

Yet, despite mounting evidence that breed plays at best a small role in determining an animal’s behavior, municipalities press on with poorly informed laws. Animal welfare advocates in the states watched a battle raging just across the northern border, where in December 2016 Montreal enacted a Pit Bull ban despite fierce opposition.

As people we abhor discrimination based upon our physical traits; why should we tolerate it against our four-legged companions? Jacksonville Humane Society’s Savanna New brings it all down to perspective.

“Shelter dogs everywhere will be much better off when potential adopters are offered only the basic physical details – along with the most important information of all: ‘My name is Jasper. I love chasing tennis balls, splashing in pools, and cuddling with little people of all ages.’”

PreviousNext

7 comments

  1. Carol McClellan says:
    March 8, 2017 at 3:34 pm

    I’m glad to see this. I have more trouble with littler dogs than I ever have with bigger ones. I agree with the idea that , like humans, there are good ones and there are bad ones no matter what breed it is. It’s the training rather than the breed.

  2. Ryann Jackson says:
    March 7, 2017 at 10:55 am

    Best article ever!! I love my two rescued “pit-bull” breeds. They are perfect for our family, they are great with our now 13-month-old baby, as well as our 4 year and 2 year old nieces. Our desire to save a life brought us to adopt a puppy from a rescue shelter and 8 months later, adopt another one. We wouldn’t have it any other way!

    1. bethz says:
      March 7, 2017 at 11:04 am

      Thanks for sharing your family’s positive experience with Pitties, Ryann – and for choosing adoption!

  3. Mary Eaton says:
    March 7, 2017 at 10:00 am

    It’s good to start out a day with such positive feedback Mary. This article was very informative. Kudos and props to Beth and her team. 🙂

    1. bethz says:
      March 7, 2017 at 11:05 am

      Thanks, Mary; we have a very dedicated team who care deeply about these issues. Glad you liked the article!

  4. Mary J Armbrust says:
    March 7, 2017 at 9:49 am

    I love the idea of “no labels.” Dogs are awesome and there’s one out there for everyone. I love how young they make you feel when you have one. I feel six years old with my Gumby f/k/a Pedro the Goofy, at my side. He loves me and makes everything we do a “caper” – whether it’s doing household chores, watching a TV show or taking a walk outside. Gumby is a purebred American Staffordshire Terrier – one of the “pit bull” breeds. He could crush my bones with his jaws at any time – most dogs can, but he loves me so I don’t even think about that when we’re playing in the backyard. There are no bad breeds of dogs – only bad people.

    1. bethz says:
      March 7, 2017 at 11:04 am

      So right, Mary; the only labels that should matter are the ones you use to describe how much you love your dog.

Comments are closed.

Join the Conversation

  • Cat tales
  • Dog tales
  • Hope for a home
  • Mental health
  • Extra
  • Pet training & health
  • Donor News


Give with Confidence

logo logo logo logo
Make a donation today
email-icon

Did you enjoy this story?
Don’t miss the next one.

Sign up for our newsletter and get stories like these directly in your inbox.


The Dodo and GEICO honor Pets for Patriots adoptions by sharing their heartwarming tales

WATCH THE VIDEOS

Petco Foundation

PetMeds Logo 300x250

Shop 1800PetMeds for all of your pet’s health needs and we’ll get 10% of your purchase!

Shop Bissell Today!

Shop BISSELL for your home cleaning needs and they will donate 10% of your purchase to us!

Join the Conversation

Stay Connected

Join the conversation, read recent adoption stories, view featured pets needing new homes and more.

Twitter

@petsforpatriots

Follow Us

Instagram

@petsforpatriots

Senior pets are among those most overlooked at she Senior pets are among those most overlooked at shelters. But one old dog is living proof that mature pets can breathe new life into their adopted homes.

Click the link in our bio to read the inspiring story of Chuck, a retired Coastie, and his 10 year-old bud Wayne!

Thank you @fairfieldcodog for this amazing match and waiving adoption fees for veterans we serve.

#coastguard #coastguardveterans #coastie #uscg #milspouse #militaryspouse #petsforvets #olddogs #olddogsrule #adoptaseniordog #weratedogs
Lance enlisted in the Marines in 2016 and ever sin Lance enlisted in the Marines in 2016 and ever since he separated from service he longed for the companionship of a rescue dog. 

The Marine Corps veteran met Marty, an adult Pittie mix, through @bmorehumane, which waives fees for veterans in our program.

In a 'freedom ride' message Lance shared with us he introduced Marty as his son - and we wish this new dog dad many happy years together with his new boy!!

#usmcveteran #usmc #marinecorps #marinecorpsveteran #devildog #pibble #dontbullymybreed #dontbullymybully #loveabully #adoptdontshop #petsforvets
Puppy mills are places of unspeakable cruelty. The Puppy mills are places of unspeakable cruelty. They exist solely because of greed and a callous disregard for the lives of animals.

Thanks to @bissellpets for sharing this informative graphic on how to spot a likely puppy mill. Please share in kind and - needless to say - always adopt, don't shop!

#adoptdontshop #endpuppymills #animalcruelty #animalcrueltyawareness #adoptionistheonlyoption #adoptashelterdog #adoptasheltercat #adoptashelterpet #rescueismyfavoritebreed
Maisie, Hawk, Mosley, Betty White, Annie, Sammy, T Maisie, Hawk, Mosley, Betty White, Annie, Sammy, Talahassee, Juju, Corn, and Pierogi - just some of the long term pets waiting way too long for a hero and a home. Meet all of our Forget Me Not pets and contact the shelters directly to inquire about adoption. Many are available for out-of-state placements; all are amazing creatures in desperate need of a loving home and all deserve no less.

Can't adopt? Share til it hurts!!

Click the link in our bio to meet them all.

#forgetmenot #weratedogs #weratecats #adoptdontshop #adoptashelterpet #adoptashelterdog #adoptasheltercat #cutedogs #cutedogsofinstagram #cutecats
Meet our recent "K" adopters, m'kay? * Kricket is Meet our recent "K" adopters, m'kay?

* Kricket is retired Navy and recently visited our partners @kitsaphumanesociety where she adopted not one, not two, but THREE petite pups! Reina pictured here is @petsforpatriots eligible, as is Remy (not pictured). But Kricket wasn't done saving lives because she threw yet another lifeline to Dior to round out her perfect petite pupper family! Thanks to @kitsaphumanesociety for giving our veterans 50% off adoption fees...anchors aweigh! 

* Konner served in the Air Force and together with his beautiful partner welcomed 4 year-old Hammer into their home. Formerly named Lucretia, Hammer is a beneficiary of our hero fund for veterinary care to help with the initial costs of prescriptions to ease pain from patellar luxation (a fancy way of saying: knee problems)! Another great fee-waived adoption through @dekalbanimals - part of the trio of @lifelineanimal shelters that participate in our program. 

Every animal saved from a shelter makes room for another animal in need to be rescued. It's estimated that only 25% of dogs and 29% of cats are adopted through shelters, numbers that are frankly pathetic. Please continue to advocate for adoption as the only option!

#adoptdontshop #adoptdontbuy #adoptashelterpet #adoptashelterdog #pitbulllove #loveabully #dontbullymybreed #cutepup #weratedogs #navyveteran #navy #airforceveteran #airforce #usaf #femaleveteran
The impacts of serving in the Gulf War left John w The impacts of serving in the Gulf War left John with crippling, severe anxiety. A spirited hound who needed a home would be just what the Army veteran needed to regain his life.

Click the link in our bio to read their tale, and thanks once again to @bmorehumane for another lifesaving match!

#army #armyveteran #milspouse #militaryspouse #ptsd #ptsdrecovery #ptsdawareness #anxiety #anxietyawareness #gulfwar #gulfwarveteran #petsforvets #houndsofinstagram #cutedogs #weratedogs #yourarenotalone
Clark retired from the Marines after more than 20 Clark retired from the Marines after more than 20 years of service to our nation. And in 2012 he was one of our early adopters - literally and figuratively - when he rescued then 2 year-old Ellie.

Ellie is now 13 and the pint-sized pup is still living large with Clark and his family, who recently gave us this heartfelt shoutout:

"Wanted to thank you for the many years of support your team has provided! It has helped out immensely over the years! Thank you all for what you have done and for what you continue to do."

Sounds like a mission accomplished to us!

Thanks to our partners @ranchocoastal - one of our earliest shelter partners - for this enduring match, and for continuing to waive adoption fees for veterans in our program.

#gotchadayanniversary #adoptdontshop #adoptashelterdog #adoptashelterpet #militaryfamily #usmcveteran #usmc #marinecorps #usmarines #usmarinecorps #petsforvets
Ahoy, mate! Noah retired from the Navy and just th Ahoy, mate! Noah retired from the Navy and just threw a lifeline to Kali, a stunning Cane Corso mix. This big, beautiful girl was in the care of our partners @norfolkanimals which gives veterans we serve 50% off adoption fees.

Click to the next photo to see their freedom ride pic!

#canecorsoofinstagram #canecorso #bigdogs #bigdogsofinstagram #bigdogstrong #adoptdontshop #adoptashelterpet #adoptashelterdog #weratedogs #navyveteran #navy #usn #usnavy #norfolkva
CJ is a disabled Marine veteran who finds joy in t CJ is a disabled Marine veteran who finds joy in the simple pleasures of life, including the addition of an older cat who joined her after the loss of a beloved pet.

Click the link in our bio to read their tale!

Thanks @sdhumanesociety for helping us make this purr-fect story possible and for waiving adoption fees for veterans in our program. ❤️

#sdhumanesociety #femaleveteran #usmcveteran #usmc #marinecorps #cats_of_instagram #cutecat #cutecats #cutecatsofinstagram #nalacat #adoptasheltercat #adoptaseniorpet #oldcatsofinstagram #oldcats #twoisbetterthanone
Follow Us

© 2023 Pets for Patriots, Inc. | Privacy policy | Terms of use | Contact us

email-icon

Let’s keep in touch.

Sign up for our newsletter to get recent adoption stories, featured pets needing new homes and more directly in your inbox.

email-icon

Let’s keep in touch.

Sign up for our newsletter to get recent adoption stories, featured pets needing new homes and more directly in your inbox.

email-icon

Let’s keep in touch.

Sign up for our newsletter to get recent adoption stories, featured pets needing new homes and more directly in your inbox.